“We're Making It Hard on Our GM to Sell”: Blue Jackets’ Playoff Push Changes Trade Deadline Plans

6 min read
Mar 2, 2025, 12:00 PM
Adam Fantilli #19 of the Columbus Blue Jackets scores an empty-net goal against the Detroit Red Wings

The Blue Jackets’ playoff push has GM Don Waddell rethinking the NHL Trade Deadline (Photo by Jason Mowry/Getty Images)

The Columbus Blue Jackets are making many people believe this season. Columbus continues to win hockey games and come together as a team after the tragedy surrounding Johnny and Matthew Gaudreau.

Expectations were not high for Columbus entering the season, but the Blue Jackets find themselves in a battle in the Eastern Conference wild card race with the Detroit Red Wings, whom they played in the 2025 Stadium Series.

Given the circumstances, it was a crucial game and stretch for the Blue Jackets, with two massive points on the line. Colubmus has positioned itself no longer as sellers but buyers at the NHL Trade Deadline on March 7th. That is a credit to players coming together as a team and playing the right way.

“We're making it hard on our GM to be a seller,” Fantilli said exclusively to RG.

Columbus sits just four points back of the New Jersey Devils for third in the Metro Division as they maintain a hold on one of the wildcard positions in the East. That is a credit to head coach Dean Evason and the players believing in each other. However, as sources told RG, the GM Don Waddell has to look at the deadline a lot differently now.

“The team has done a tremendous job putting themselves in this position and making his job a little tougher,” a source said. “He thought he would be a seller completely by the deadline, but now management is looking at things a little differently.”

We have seen that the Blue Jackets general manager is not afraid to make moves. He will move him if a player does not want to be in Columbus. As RG reported, David Jiricek wanted out of Columbus, but he eventually got dealt to the Minnesota Wild.

However, Waddell, like all GMs in the league, are balancing a fine line between making the playoffs and waving the white flag. As RG reported, the sellers that many contending teams thought would be there are not, with Columbus looking more like buyers every passing day.

Waddell knows he has to be smart about managing his assets, as the Blue Jackets are a team on the rise. He does not want to give away a first-round pick or a player who will be part of this core moving forward. But if there is an opportunity to add a player who can help the core long-term, he is open to it.

“His job is to get them into the playoffs, like every GM's job is, but he has to balance and carefully manage his assets moving forward. He is still evaluating what he has in the system. Why would he trade a first round pick for a rental?,” the source told RG.

“Now, if it was for a player with term? That's a little different, that the team could move forward with that a bit differently. But he is looking to see if he can tweak things here and there.”

Looking To Bolster Scoring

While goal scoring has not been a problem for the Blue Jackets this season, Columbus is expected to look to add up front.

"They certainly want to add as they have got injuries up front," the source added to RG. "They are a little short handed up front, so that's the position that management is really looking at."

It makes sense with the injury to Cole Sillinger, the Blue Jackets want to replace his productivity. This is a change of tune from earlier in the season when Waddel told RG he was not going to make moves based on injury. However, his situation has changed with the team in the playoff mix.

As we have seen, it never hurts to have too much depth, especially come playoff time. It helps to have depth on offense and defense. But the question is who the Blue Jackets will target.

The Blue Jackets are looking to bolster their scoring depth and are actively in talks to make some additions. According to a well-placed source, the Blue Jackets were also in talks to acquire veteran winger Gustav Nyquist, before he was ultimately traded to the Minnesota Wild on Saturday.

“He was a player the Blue Jackets would have liked to have come back. He fit in the first time, has ties to some of the younger players on the team, and it would have given them more secondary scoring.”

With Columbus in a playoff position as the deadline approaches, there is a belief that they will make or move to help them make the playoffs.

There are quite a few depth forwards still available on the trade front and the Blue Jackets appear to have reached a decision to be buyers heading into the deadline.

Jim Biringer
Jim Biringer
Reporter

Having 10 years of experience (SiriusXM NHL Network Radio, Rod Pedersen Show, Raw Mike Richards Show, and more) covering the Devils, the NHL along with College Football, the NFL, and the tennis circuit Jim Biringer has wealth of sports knowledge. As one of Jim's hockey coaches put it he is a "student of the game." During his time as a sports reporter, Biringer has covered some of the biggest events including most recently the 2024 Stanley Cup Final along with several NHL Drafts. He is also the host of the Full Press Hockey Podcast and Final Word on Hockey plus Around Campus - The College Football Podcast.

Interests:
NFL
NHL
College Football

More RG Exclusive Interviews

Hockey
05/08/2025
James Murphy
James Murphy
“He’s A Really Boston-Type Guy”: Rick Tocchet Emerges As Top Bruins Target For Head Coach Role
Former Bruin Rick Tocchet is now the leading candidate for Boston’s head coach job, sources confirm to RG
“He’s A Really Boston-Type Guy”: Rick Tocchet Emerges As Top Bruins Target For Head Coach Role
Hockey
05/05/2025
James Murphy
James Murphy
Exclusive: “I Want To Play 65 Games A Year…I Want To Be The Man!” Spencer Knight Embraces New Role In Chicago
Traded to Chicago, goalie Spencer Knight reflects on personal growth, embracing leadership, and guiding young superstar Connor Bedard
Exclusive: “I Want To Play 65 Games A Year…I Want To Be The Man!” Spencer Knight Embraces New Role In Chicago
Hockey
05/01/2025
Jim Biringer
Jim Biringer
“They Were Asking Too Much”: Why the Devils Passed on Predators’ High Price for Ryan O’Reilly
The Devils chose depth over Ryan O’Reilly, unwilling to meet Nashville’s steep trade demands involving key young players and draft picks
“They Were Asking Too Much”: Why the Devils Passed on Predators’ High Price for Ryan O’Reilly
Hockey
04/30/2025
James Murphy
James Murphy
“He’s A Smart Kid; He’s A Great Goalie”: Spencer Knight Cheers Canadiens Prospect Jacob Fowler
Chicago Blackhawks goalie Spencer Knight praises Canadiens prospect Jacob Fowler’s playoff debut with Laval, highlighting mentorship and future NHL promise
“He’s A Smart Kid; He’s A Great Goalie”: Spencer Knight Cheers Canadiens Prospect Jacob Fowler
Prev
...
Next

Hockey Writers

James Murphy
James Murphy
NHL Reporter

With 24 years of experience (SiriusXM NHL Network Radio, ESPN Boston, NESN, NHL.com, etc.) covering the Bruins, the NHL, NCAA and junior hockey, and more, Jimmy Murphy’s hockey black book is filled with Hall of Famers, current players, coaches, management, scouts and a wide array of hockey media personalities that have lived in and around this great game. For 22 of his 24 years as a hockey and sports reporter, Murphy covered the Bruins on a daily basis, including their victorious 2011 Stanley Cup run and their runs to the 2013 and 2019 Finals. Murphy is currently a co-host, along with Pierre McGuire, on The Eye Test Podcast.

Meet All Our Experts
This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. Read our
Privacy Policy
.