Eli Manning Makes Bold NFL MVP Prediction, Talks Sam Darnold and Daniel Jones

7 min read
Jan 8, 2025, 12:01 PM
Sam Darnold #14 of the Minnesota Vikings leaves the field after beating the Green Bay Packers 27-25

Sam Darnold #14 of the Minnesota Vikings leaves the field after beating the Green Bay Packers 27-25 (Photo by Brace Hemmelgarn/Getty Images)

New York Giants great Eli Manning knows all about thriving under the pressure of playing in the biggest media market in the country.

The Pro Football Hall of Fame finalist won two Super Bowls and did so against the best quarterback of all time in Tom Brady and the best dynasty in NFL history in the New England Patriots. However, not every quarterback is built to have that type of success.

Daniel Jones had some success in New York, helping lead the Giants to a surprise playoff appearance and an upset win over the Minnesota Vikings in the 2022 playoffs. That single-season performance earned him a four-year, $160 million deal and the status as a franchise quarterback for the Giants.

However, that success was short-lived with Jones eventually finding himself benched after going 3-13 over the past two seasons. Jones and the Giants both parted ways midway through the 2024 season with the former No. 6 pick latching on with the Vikings as a backup quarterback.

Manning – who himself was supplanted as the starting quarterback by Jones in 2019 – says it'll be interesting to see how the situation unfolds in Minnesota considering Sam Darnold isn't guaranteed to return next year as he hits free agency.

"We'll see what they have in mind for Daniel," says Manning in a one-on-one interview with RG on behalf of his partnership with Verizon. "It probably depends on what happens in these first couple of weeks in the playoffs."

Jones could find himself competing for the starting quarterback job with 2024 first-round pick J.J. McCarthy next year, if Darnold prices himself out of the Vikings' pay range. Darnold, himself a former 2019 first-round pick, has had the best season of his career while leading Minnesota to a surprising 14-3 season.

" It'll be an interesting situation to see what happens with Sam Darnold," says Manning.

"I'm excited for Sam. I've known Sam a long time since he was in college and obviously a situation where it work out here in New York with the Jets. He moved around, was a backup in different spots and worked his way into a position where he got the opportunity to play here in Minnesota and took full advantage of it."

While Darnold isn't being mentioned in the MVP conversation with the likes of Lamar Jackson and Josh Allen, he certainly has a resume that matches up with the two favorites. Along with his 14-3 record – the second-best mark in the NFL – the 26-year-old ranks in the top six in passing yards, touchdowns and passer rating.

"Getting 14 wins, going into the playoffs, proud of his commitment, his desire and his work ethic through this process to get back and play at such a high level," says Manning. "Probably in the MVP talk this year of what a great season he had. Minnesota has to figure out what they're going to do with him next year: signing him back or letting him test the waters in free agency."

Bold NFL MVP Choice

Speaking of the MVP conversation, Allen is still considered the favorite with Jackson as the next betting favorite. It's clear that voters may lean towards the Buffalo Bills quarterback due to the Bills' strong season despite a weak offensive supporting cast and due to the fact that Allen has led two victories over the best teams in the league in the Kansas City Chiefs and Detroit Lions.

What also may help Allen's cause is that he's never won the MVP award before. In fact, he's never won a major award in his career despite being considered an elite quarterback over the past several years. That combined with voter fatigue for Jackson – who has won two MVP awards – may ultimately earn Allen his first MVP award.

However, Manning would go with Jackson as his pick for MVP.

"Lamar Jackson, especially his last five weeks, how he's played, 41 touchdowns, four interceptions, pretty impressive what he's done and I know he's won them before – but that shouldn't hurt you," says Manning. "If you have the best season, if you've played the best, he should win MVP. I think it should probably go to Lamar."

Manning's former teammate, Saquon Barkley, has lost steam in the MVP race due to sitting out Week 18 and missing out on his opportunity in breaking Eric Dickerson's 40-year-old rushing record. However, he acknowledges that Barkley deserves serious consideration for the MVP award for having one of the seasons of all time.  

"I think Saquon should be in the mix," says Manning. "If he plays the last game of the regular season against the Giants, he breaks Eric Dickerson's rushing record. The fact that he's in the mix and close to breaking a rushing record that's been around for a long time in a pass-happy league where they're not rushing the ball as much as they used to, it's so impressive."

Manning – who teamed with Barkley during the running back's first two seasons in the league – calls him an "unbelievable" teammate and says he's "excited" to be going to the playoffs after making only one appearance as a member of the Giants.  

"He was an unbelievable teammate, honored to have played with him and happy for his success this year," says Barkley. "I know he's excited to be on a playoff team, going through the playoffs and definitely throwing his name in the mix [in the MVP conversation]."

DJ Siddiqi
DJ Siddiqi
Sports Reporter

DJ Siddiqi is a sports reporter who focuses on football, basketball and pro wrestling. He has covered some of the biggest sporting events, including the NBA Finals and Wrestlemania and often interviews high-profile athletes on a weekly basis. Siddiqi has interviewed the likes of Dan Marino, Emmitt Smith, Shaquille O'Neal, Tony Hawk and Giannis Antetokounmpo. His previous experience includes working as a lead NBA writer at CBS Sports and 247 Sports in addition to working as a beat reporter covering the NFL and the Denver Broncos at Bleacher Report. Follow Siddiqi for exclusive one-on-one interviews and analysis on key topics in sports

Interests:
NFL
NBA
NCAAF
NCAAB
NHL
Travel
Interviews

More RG Exclusive Interviews

04/24/2025
“A Great Addition for the Rams”: Puka Nacua on Possible Ramsey Comeback
Puka Nacua talks Rams’ future, teaming with Davante Adams, and battling Cooper Kupp’s Seahawks twice in 2025
“A Great Addition for the Rams”: Puka Nacua on Possible Ramsey Comeback
04/23/2025
“We Need That Spark To Ignite Cowboys” – DeMarcus Ware Demands Ground-And-Pound Revival In Dallas
Cowboys icon DeMarcus Ware pushes Dallas to revive their rushing offense, calling for a dynamic pick at No. 12 in the NFL Draft
“We Need That Spark To Ignite Cowboys” – DeMarcus Ware Demands Ground-And-Pound Revival In Dallas
04/22/2025
“You’re So Scarred From Playing Lamar”: Steelers Need a QB Who Makes Rivals Worry, Says Orlovsky
ESPN’s Dan Orlovsky believes the Steelers must draft a dynamic QB like Jalen Milroe to challenge Lamar Jackson and Baltimore
“You’re So Scarred From Playing Lamar”: Steelers Need a QB Who Makes Rivals Worry, Says Orlovsky
04/17/2025
"It Would Be Dope" — Ashton Jeanty Talks Potential Cowboys Draft and Hometown Dreams
Boise State phenom Ashton Jeanty aims to rush for 1,000 yards as a rookie and dreams of a 2,000-yard NFL season in the future
"It Would Be Dope" — Ashton Jeanty Talks Potential Cowboys Draft and Hometown Dreams
04/07/2025
“I Just Wanted to Show I Could Move”: Xander Mueller Poised to Be Next Northwestern Star to Reach the NFL
Xander Mueller, mentored by NU greats, eyes the 2025 NFL Draft after standout college career and strong Pro Day
“I Just Wanted to Show I Could Move”: Xander Mueller Poised to Be Next Northwestern Star to Reach the NFL
04/06/2025
Ronde Barber Backs Bucs: Hall of Famer Says Tampa Bay Can Compete With NFC’s Best, Led by Mike Evans
Ronde Barber believes the Buccaneers are built to win now, with stars like Mike Evans and Baker Mayfield leading the charge
Ronde Barber Backs Bucs: Hall of Famer Says Tampa Bay Can Compete With NFC’s Best, Led by Mike Evans
04/01/2025
"It Was Really Exciting": Danny Stutsman on Meeting With Dallas Cowboys at NFL Combine
NFL Draft prospect and former Oklahoma Sooners linebacker Danny Stutsman names the teams he met with at the NFL Combine and how the Dallas Cowboys meeting stood out to him
"It Was Really Exciting": Danny Stutsman on Meeting With Dallas Cowboys at NFL Combine
03/27/2025
“Saquon Changed the Conversation About Running Backs” – Barry Sanders on Barkley’s Impact, Mount Rushmore of RBs
Detroit Lions great Barry Sanders details how the Philadelphia Eagles’ Saquon Barkley has brought value back to running backs and names his Mount Rushmore for the position
“Saquon Changed the Conversation About Running Backs” – Barry Sanders on Barkley’s Impact, Mount Rushmore of RBs
03/26/2025
“They Both Want to Win”: Patrick Surtain II Praises Bo Nix-Sean Payton Duo Driving Broncos’ Resurgence
Patrick Surtain II highlights how Bo Nix and Sean Payton’s shared mindset sparked a playoff return for the Broncos
“They Both Want to Win”: Patrick Surtain II Praises Bo Nix-Sean Payton Duo Driving Broncos’ Resurgence
03/19/2025
Braden Fiske on Los Angeles Rams' Decision to Move On From Cooper Kupp: "Obviously, It Was Tough”
Braden Fiske opens up on the Los Angeles Rams' decision to move on from Cooper Kupp and his thoughts on the addition of Davante Adams
Braden Fiske on Los Angeles Rams' Decision to Move On From Cooper Kupp:  "Obviously, It Was Tough”

NFL Writers

Crissy Froyd
Crissy Froyd
Football Reporter

Crissy Froyd is a sports reporter of over 10 years who specializes in quarterback analysis at the high school, college and NFL level. She was mentored by Mike Leach and learned the Air Raid offense and quarterback evaluation largely under the legendary head coach. Froyd has appeared in and worked with multiple publications, including USA TODAY SMG, Sports Illustrated, NBC Sports and Saturday Down South. She also covers canine journalism for Showsight Magazine and resides in Wisconsin with her three dogs -- two German Shepherds named Faxon and Bo Nix, and one Siberian Husky named Stetson "Balto" Bennett.

Meet All Our Experts